Malaysian Indian lawmaker in trouble with government

Guility

Nobody is feeling guilty out here , but people like you passing silly comments. I never expected that the PM could involve in this . Double standards is very obvious out here. Malu betul

calling for freedom of expression without persecution

it is of utmost importance that the primeminister looks into equality and justice of its citizens instead of letting them to rot under isa .ie hindraf and now the next to be victim mr karpal .the learned perak sultan has
not uttered a word the prime minister should take the cue and lay off.

In reality this is a very simple and straightforward case. The MB of Perak while transfering a state servant had erred in customs only. He overlooked the procedures that need to be taken. A call for reinstatement was made by the Sultan. The state government was not fast enough to take the necessary action and exercise damage control. Various parties began to voice out their opinions. Mr. Karpal Singh, whose party is part of the state government, then voiced out his views for the consideration of the State government. The ruling party then sees it appropriate to mount an attack by taking up the issue under the pretex of this and that. Certainly, the Sultan can understand the opinion from Mr. Karpal Singh because of his judicial background. Of course the matter is subject to deliberation or just for academic purposes. But, for the ruling party to spin on the issue is like seeing an opportunist in action trying to act as a hero and to distract their supporters from other more important issues. As such, how can they earn our(the people at large, with no vested interest in politics) respect? how can they win our hearts and minds? I do not see 'good governance' within this context.

Law Tested

I wonder why all irrelevent politicians are jumping into the wagon. My biggest question is why neither Sultan Azlan Shah as former Lord President nor Datuk Zaid Ibrahim, our infamous Law Minister is yet to comment on the issue. Even Raja Nazrin Shah who in recent times issued stinging adresses on good governance is silent on the matter. Looks like Mr. Karpal is right by law and wrong by lawless.

freedom of expression

the sultan of perak,alearned man ,aman of high standing has not said anything aginst mr karpal as he is just man and allows freedom of speech i dont see why the the prime minister should want to clamp a sedation charge against him. let those ruling the country look into the countrys welfare.

Double Standards

Now that Karpal merely made a point of law, it has been construed as seditious by Barisan 'Nut’sional capers. However, when these goons were disobedient to the rulers of Perlis and Trengganu, it wasn’t the case. The silence from the BN leaders and their stooge(Ibrahim Ali) on this (being rude to Rulers of Perlis and Trengganu) is embarassingly deafening!!

Its this sort of hypocrisy that got them rotten egged in the last elections.

Bodoh

To Mr, do you understand really what is happening. what is all this double standards. when Tun Mahathir could organise ralies during the constitutional crsis it was ok now for Kirpal it is not ok. The people are not Bodoh , those who understand that is. You are real Bodoh

without fear or favour

i would like to say to kapal,
SIAPA MAKAN CABAI, DIA AKAN RASA PEDAS.

sedition this, sedition that!!

What kind of country has Malaysian turned into communist? Just recently we have a blogger, now, a law maker to be charged under sedition law? Might as well let UMNO declared the country as communist or run by the junta like Burma, then they can do whatever sedition on any one they wish, with no question asked! What about the UMNO law makers thenmselves who questions the authority of the Sultans of Trengganu and Perlis?? To be fair they too should be under the gun! We are living in the 21st century, the citizens are educated and tech savy and we are not to be controlled like kids or robots as they wished. How can we be in the 1st world in 2020? Malaysia boleh or tak boleh???

Is the Perak Sultan more superior than the Agong?

Why is anyone comparing this situation to the case where a few MPs in Terrengganu questioned and if I am not mistaken boycotted the swearing of the Terrenggany MB of the Terrengganu’s Sultan’s choice....infact the Agong’s choice. Is the Perak Sultan in someway more superior to his majesty...the Agong? Or is it because it was done by the UMNOputeras who seem to be immuned to everything they do on the streets?

he who is wrong will feel guity

if you are not wrong why feel guilty, so who is a real bodoh you or mr.

what???

I question the jurisdiction of anyone who thinks they can prosecute anyone for speaking their mind. Malaysia shows it true colours more and more if one even considers prosecution for a citizen that is just using a basic right of freedom of speech. So I ask??? Does Malaysia believe in “Freedom of Speech”???? Apparently Not!!!!!!! If they have to discuss this Sultan’s actions. Yipes, lets look at this closely. The lawmaker is Indian right???? It may become more clearer to the reader what is really at issure here.

Malaysian Indian lawmaker in trouble with government

We are making a issue out of tissue this matter and its prerogative are in Monarch’s hand ,all this days umno only used the monarch for thier personnel benefits and now they are trying to be in a good books of sultan’s.
becouse of the monarch’s power which i believe the most learned sultan in M’sia and the most respecful family in Asia is sultanate of perak ,its up to his highness to forgive and to respond or punish as per his will’s.

Where is the Sedition?

So what did Karpal Singh say?
"....that Sultan Azlan Shah had no jurisdiction over the transfer of the official, who had been issued a 24-hour transfer order by Perak’s Mentri Besar (chief minister) Mohamad Nizar Jamaluddin April 29."
Is that the issue here?
You don’t need too much intelligence to conclude that there is no Sedition in that statement.
Anyone can question the jurisdiction of anyone, including the royalty similar to the fashion UMNO under Dr. Mahathir Mohammad did during its crisis with the royalty a decade ago.
Right or wrong, justified or unjustified, sedition is crystally absent in Karpal’s statement.

Look at the bigger picture

I am surprised and dismayed that Abdullah is wasting precious time on this seditious issue. Come on, there are many other bigger issues to think about and to implement instead of this small minded issue. For a start, can we have more transparency in all govt agencies, get rid of corruption, more press freedom and the release of all ISA detainees??

If Abdullah wants the AG to rush this to court, then be fair and also bring the UMNO ex-minister who grabbed a woman’s bottom to justice or at least name and shame him in public!

Look at the bigger picture and stop scoring political mileage on this - PM!!

names of Sultan is Parameswaran not Parameswara or Lakshmana

BUDDHIST SRIVIJAYAN WAS FROM"CHOLAMANDALAM COAST OF INDIA” MAY BE FROM BENGAL.
The Sultanate of Malacca was founded by Parameswara in 1402 and later married the princess of Pasai in 1409. Centered in the modern town of Malacca, the sultanate stretched from southern Thailand in the north to Sumatra in the southwest. The Portuguese invaded its capital in 1511 and in 1528, the Sultanate of Johor was established by a Malaccan prince to succeed Malacca.
With the Portuguese and Johor frequently locking horns, Aceh launched multiple raids against both sides in order to tighten its grip on the straits. The rise of Aceh encouraged the Portuguese and Johor to sign a truce and divert their attention to Aceh

THE SOVEREIGNTY OF “MALAYSIA and INDONESIA” SHOULD BE PROTECTED UNDER THE SOVEREIGNTIES OF “INDIA and CHINA” ATLEAST NOW -“NO MORE OPIUM WAR”!!-WE ARE NOT UNDER ADICTIONS.

Sultans gangsterTalk

Talk good you OK la. Talk bad about sultan you go to jail. No joke Muthusamy. Don’t cofuse yourself, we are still 500 years behind civilisation in malaya.

no takers

to all friends of this soil malaysia malays.indian and chinese there are no takers we are on loan to this soil call earth our sad to see you people claming my soil my land in fact the truth is you dont claim anything as sadly you dont take anything with you nor your children you know what be happy and thankful for the peace and beauty of the nation call malaysia its about progress and advancement of a nation not about a race,why talk about the jews nor the chinese we should have our own identity we are malaysian think malaysian talk malaysian act malaysian no body can touch us because we are one malaysian give the malaysian malays,indians and chinese a chance to be malaysian we are on our way to progress and advancement,achievement yes its true take it...............

HONESTY IS THE BEST POLICY

TO ALL THE CROOKES ESPECIALLY UMNO POLITICIAN MOHAMMAD MOHAMMAD TAIB,THE 3
MILLION CROOKE,THAMBI CHICK THE PERVERT WHO SUCK YOUNG SCHOOL GOING CHILDREN AND MOHAMMAD ISA THE SHOT ASS LAND DISPUTE ARENT YOU GUYS ASHAME OF YOURSELF WHAT YOUR RELIGION TEACHERS YOU HOW MUCH CAN YOU GUYS GO WITH THE CRIME BEHIND YOUR
BACK BE CAREFUL YOUR KIDS WILL HAVE TO PAY NO CHOICE THAT is the game YOU CHOOSE TO PLAY WAIT YOU WILL SEE AND I WILL ALSO SEE .................

between a snake and a indian

what a subject to talk is that why we choose a lady to represent the community please how sad the pm is keeping cool to such a talk isnt there someone out there to show the lady minister where she comes from maybe from one of the indian snakes making hope she understandas the gravity................